STIFEL - Retail REIT Comp Sheets 8/29/16
REITs were down 0.44% last week, but are up 12.9% YTD. Retail REITs are slightly outperforming the REIT index YTD, up 13.1%, as regional malls are up 11.6% and shopping centers are up 15.5%.
|
|
STIFEL: GPT ($9.62, Buy) - Disposition Volume Exceeds Initial Targets & Ahead Of Schedule
Disposition Volume Exceeds Initial Targets & Ahead Of Schedule
Capital Recycling Plan At GPT. Last summer, Gramercy Property Trust's management put together and presented a capital recycling plan to reshape the company's portfolio post the closing of the merger with CSG. The merger closed in mid-December andGPT has executed on that plan over the last eight months. With the recent sale of four assets, GPT has exceeded its original plan to sell $1.15-$1.23 billion over a 24-month period. We believe, once all of the sale proceeds are redeployed, the company should have a high-quality portfolio with predictable and growing cash flows and a strong balance sheet that should result in a higher multiple.
Triple-Net Sector Has Lagged MTD. The triple-net sector has been lagging MTD -6.5% vs. the RMS -3.8%. The sector has underperformed due to the possibility of the Fed raising rates at the upcoming meeting in September
GPT Has Lagged Triple-Net Sector YTD. YTD, GPT is up 27.8% vs. the triple-net sector +31.5% and RMS +13.9%.
Presented Plan At Investor Day Last September To Reposition Portfolio. Last September, management presented a plan to reposition the combined CSG/GPT portfolio by selling assets in two phases. The first phase was to take place throughout 2016 and was intended to reduce the company's exposure to non-strategic multi-tenant and single tenant suburban office assets by selling $725-$775 million at a 6.2%-6.7% cash cap rate. The second phase was to take place over the longer-term, by year-end 2017 and hoped to sell $420-$450 million of office assets with shorter lease terms at a 7.3%-7.9% cap rate. In total, GPT hoped to sell $1.145-$1.225 billion of assets at an average cap rate of 6.7%-7.2%.
Sells Four More Assets. Yesterday, the company announced that it has sold three more single-tenant office buildings in Princeton, New Jersey, Burlington, Massachusetts, and Bloomington, Minnesota as well as a single-tenant industrial property in Phoenix, Arizona for $206.7 million or a 7.4% forward cash cap rate. The properties had a weighted average lease term of 10.1 years.
Has Exceeded Expectations With Over $1.26 Billion Sold. YTD, GPT has sold $1.26 billion of primarily single and multi-tenant office assets at a weighted average 6.6% cap rate.
More Assets Under Contract & Being Marketed. The company has $158.6 million of assets under contract with an additional $117.8 million being marketed. If those sales close, total dispositions would be $1.5 billion at a 6.8% cap rate, over 12 months ahead of the anticipated schedule.
Use Of Proceeds. Management intends to use the proceeds from asset sales and balance sheet capacity to reach a target asset allocation of 75% industrial and 25% office/specialty.
Acquisition Update. In 2Q, GPT purchased $354.9 million of assets at a 7.3% cap rate with a weighted average lease term of 12.0 years. QTD, an additional $155.2 million have closed at a 6.6% cap rate with a weighted average lease term of 12.1 years. An additional $342.6 million of assets are under contract/LOI at a 6.75% cap rate with a weighted average lease term of 12.2 years. Total acquisitions are $905.5 million at a 7.0% cap rate with a 12.4 year weighted average lease term
U.S. Portfolio As Of 12/31. As of 12/31, U.S. portfolio NOI consisted of 47.0% office, 45.0% industrial, and 8.0% specialty retail.
Pro Forma For The Current Sales. Pro forma U.S. portfolio NOI consists of 60.7% industrial, 34.7% office, and 4.6% specialty retail. Office exposure will continue to come down as sale proceeds are recycled into industrial assets. Management hopes to reduce office exposure to 25.0% by year-end.
Reduced Joint Venture Exposures. With the dissolution of the Duke joint venture and the sale of a large portion of the Goodman joint venture in 2Q, equity investments has been reduced from $580 million to $105 million. Unwinding most of the joint ventures, should provide a cleaner story.
Merger Fully Integrated, Synergies Ahead Of Initial Estimates. The integration with CSG was completed earlier this year. Original synergy estimates were $15 million. Realized synergies are $16-$20 million.
GPTE Gaining Scale, Taking Longer To IPO. Gramercy Europe is a joint venture between GPT, EJF Capital LLC, Fir Tree Partners, and Senator Investment Group LP. The venture owns over 30 assets with almost 10 million sf of that 100% occupied with a weighted average lease term of 8.6 years for a total purchase price of €623.0 million. Over 50.0% of the assets are located in Germany, 25.0% in the Netherlands, and the remainder in France, Poland, and the UK. The pace of capital deployment has been slower than expected.
Wide 2016 Guidance Range To Be Narrowed With 3Q Release, Could Provide 2017 Guidance. With its 2Q release, GPT maintained its 2016 core FFO and AFFO guidance of $0.66-$0.75/share. The guidance midpoint implies 15.6% FFO growth this year. The wide range was maintained as management was waiting to have a better handle on the timing of new acquisitions. Guidance will be addressed with its 3Q release. Management could also release 2017 guidance with its 3Q release. The Street is projecting high-single digit AFFO growth next, some of the highest in the sector.
Maintaining Estimates. We are maintaining our 2016, 2017, and 2018 core FFO estimates of $0.75, $0.79, and $0.84. We are maintaining our 2016 GPT-defined AFFO estimate of $0.70, $0.76, and $0.82. GPT strips out capex below AFFO. If we strip out $24 million of capex in 2016 and $16 million in 2017 to calculate AFFO, our 2016 and 2017 AFFO estimates are $0.64 and $0.73, respectively.
Expected to Address Quarterly Dividend Rate Later This Year. GPT's annual dividend payout is $0.44/share a or 4.6% dividend yield. The dividend will likely be raised later this year.
Balance Sheet. GPT has $2.24 billion of debt, $223 million of cash, and $757 million of undrawn line capacity. Gramercy’s balance sheet has net-debt+preferred to EV at 33.6% vs. the industry average of 32.7%. Net-debt+preferred/EBITDA is 4.7x, one of the lowest in the industry.
Valuation. Our 2Q NAV per share estimate of $8.25 reflects a 6.75% cap rate. Our value range of $9.25-$7.25 reflects cap rates of 6.25%-7.25%. Shares trade at an implied 6.1% cap rate.
Target Price Methodology/Risks
Our $10.50 target price reflects 12.8x our 2018 AFFO estimate of $0.82.
Risks to our target price include a prolonged economic downturn or recession, interest rate movements, and general market risk, including continued weakness in the mortgage-backed securities market and commercial real estate fundamentals.
JANNEY: REITS Mirror, Mirror: 2Q16 Revisions to Apartment Same-Store Estimates
We are updating our 2016 and 2017 same-store NOI, revenue, and expense growth estimates for the 8 major apartment REITs following 2Q16 earnings (see Figure 1). Importantly, our estimates continue to be predicated on a US economy (including job growth) and interest rates similar to today going forward. We are also not expecting any significant benefit in 2017 from the “odd year bounce” of the last few years. On a weighted average basis, we now expect 4.8% SS revenue growth and 5.5% SS NOI growth for the peer group in 2016 (-10bps from last quarter), and 4.0% and 4.4% in 2017 (-10bps from last quarter), respectively.
AIMCO (AIV) – Management SS NOI growth guidance is +5.5% to +6.5%, with a YTD actual of +5.5%. We are expecting +4.6% SS revenue growth and +5.7% SS NOI growth in 2016, and +4.0% and +4.4% in 2017. Our 2016 estimates are consistent with our previous estimates (following 1Q16 earnings), while our 2017 NOI estimate improved 30bps.
AvalonBay (AVB) – Management SS NOI growth guidance is +5.0% to 5.75%, with a YTD actual of +6.4%. We are expecting +4.7% SS revenue growth and +5.6% SS NOI growth in 2016, and +3.9% and +4.3% in 2017 based on additional softening in NYC and SF. Our 2016 estimates have been revised downward (consistent with AVB’s own guidance), while our 2017 estimates are marginally lower (-10bps).
.
Camden (CPT) – Management SS NOI growth guidance is +4.0% to +4.5%, with a YTD actual of +5.1%. We are expecting +4.2% SS revenue growth and +4.4% SS NOI growth in 2016, and +3.8% and +4.0% in 2017. Our 2016 estimates have been revised slightly upward on lower expenses, while our 2017 estimates remain unchanged.
Equity Residential (EQR) – Management SS NOI growth guidance is +3.75% to 4.25%, with a YTD actual of +5.9%. We are expecting +3.7% SS revenue growth and +4.2% SS NOI growth in 2016, and +3.6% and +3.8% in 2017 based on additional softening in NYC and SF. Our 2016 estimates have been revised downward (consistent with EQR’s own guidance), while our 2017 NOI estimate is now 40bps lower.
.
Essex (ESS) – Management SS NOI growth guidance is +7.7% to +8.5%, with a YTD actual of +8.5%. We are expecting +6.9% SS revenue growth and +8.4% SS NOI growth in 2016, and +5.4% and +6.4% in 2017 based on additional softening in NoCal. Our 2016 estimates have been revised downward by 20bps (ESS also lowered its guidance), while our 2017 estimates are roughly flat as we had been expecting some reversion to the mean on the West Coast next year.
Mid-America (MAA) – Management SS NOI growth guidance is +4.75% to +5.25%, with a YTD actual of +6.4% (note: MAA is 1 of 2 to raise their SS NOI guidance this year). We are expecting +4.3% SS revenue growth and +5.0% SS NOI growth in 2016, and +3.7% and +4.0% in 2017 as MAA has more difficult occupancy comparisons going forward. Our 2016 NOI growth has been revised upward by 70bps on both higher revenue and lower expense growth, while our 2017 NOI estimate is now 30bps higher given our expectations of continued strength. Our numbers for 2017 do not include PPS.
.
Post (PPS) – Management SS NOI growth guidance is +2.5% to +3.3%, with a YTD actual of +2.9% (note: PPS is the other that raised their SS NOI guidance this year). We are expecting +3.1% SS revenue growth and +2.7% SS NOI growth in 2016, and +3.1% and +2.7% in 2017 for the legacy PPS portfolio (PPS' announced acquisition by MAA should close by YE2016). Our 2016 NOI growth has been revised upward by 40bps on slightly higher revenue and 30bps lower expense growth.
.
UDR (UDR) – Management SS NOI growth guidance is +6.5% to +7.0%, with a YTD actual of +6.8%. We are expecting +5.6% SS revenue growth and +6.6% SS NOI growth in 2016, and +4.2% and +4.7% in 2017, making UDR second to only ESS in terms of expected 2017 performance. Our 2016 NOI growth remains in-line with our previous expectations, while our 2017 NOI estimate is now 60bps higher given our expectations of continued strength in UDR’s non-core markets.
Buy-rated AIV, MAA, and EQR remain our favorite names in the apartment REIT space.
FBR: Self-Storage REIT UPDATE
Storage REITs underperforming year to date. Storage REITs have posted a total return of –8.74% year to date, underperforming the RMS REIT Index by 2,168 bps. Last week, storage REITs were –0.33%, outperforming the RMS REIT Index by 11 bps. | |
Japan REIT sector - REITs up despite ex-dividend date for 11 REITs
Stocks should benefit from BOJ buying, REITs seem also to be in favor
TOPIX rose 2% on 29 August from the previous trading day. The main factor was likely the yen's retreat following the Fed chairwoman's lecture and comments by BOJ Governor Haruhiko Kuroda at the symposium at Jackson Hole, Wyoming, on 26 August. Amid these conditions the TSE REIT index rose 0.5% on 29 August despite it being the ex-dividend date for REITs with August-ending fiscal periods (ie, 11 of the 54 REITs). After nearly doubling its annual ETF buying target to roughly ¥6trn (from ¥3.3trn) at the 29 July Monetary Policy Meeting, the BOJ bought ¥71.9bn in ETFs on both 25 and 26 August, roughly double the daily amount of BOJ ETF buying up to 3 August. Even so, TOPIX continued to fall d-d on 25 and 26 August. On the other hand, the BOJ did not buy REITs on 25 or 26 August, but the TSE REIT index rose each day nonetheless. Judging from these market conditions, our view is that market participants feel safer in REITs than stocks.
NOMURA - Sanki Engineering (1961 JP) (Neutral) Effect of suspension not clear yet
Real estate business also warrants attention
In Apr-Jun 2016, operating losses narrowed to ¥0.3bn, from ¥0.6bn the year earlier, although Apr-Jun results make only a small contribution to full-year results owing to seasonal factors. Losses narrowed owing to an increase in revenues in the machinery systems business, offsetting an increase in provisions against construction losses in the facilities construction business, which includes the HVAC systems for buildings business. As announced by the company on 23 June, the government suspended the company from participating in bids and contracts for 30 days, from 8 July to 6 August, in connection with antitrust law violations. We will be paying close attention to the effect of the suspension on earnings in Jul-Sep and beyond. Peers that were similarly suspended in 15/3 saw earnings adversely affected in cases where the companies also refrained from actively taking on work in the private sector. We make no change to our operating profit forecasts, but we lower our target price as we cut our target P/E to 11-12x, from 16-17x previously, to reflect trends in the benchmark P/E and other factors.